Glossary
Technical deviation
Loonar · Updated 4 November 2026
A technical deviation is a point where a supplier's offer does not meet the buyer's technical specification. In a bid, the supplier declares it in writing, usually in a technical deviation list, so the buyer can evaluate it. A deviation binds the buyer only once the buyer accepts it and it is written into the contract.
Also called: deviation from specification, technical exception.
Technical deviation in a bid
An industrial RFQ or tender sets the requirements: specifications, datasheets, standards, inspection and documentation. For each one, the offer either complies or declares a deviation.
Buyers evaluate the offer as written. Many tenders state that any requirement not listed as a deviation is deemed accepted. That is why a missed requirement is costly: after award, the supplier can be held to it without having priced it.
The World Bank's standard bidding documents define a deviation as "a departure from the requirements specified in the bidding document" (World Bank, ITB 28). Public tenders follow published rules like these. Private RFQs follow the buyer's own instructions to bidders, which vary.
Technical deviation after the order
Once the contract is signed, the agreed specification is binding. Departures are handled through the contract's change and quality procedures, and the names vary by contract:
- Before manufacture: the supplier asks to depart from a requirement, usually with a deviation request, sometimes called a deviation permit. Work goes ahead only after the buyer's written approval.
- After manufacture: a product that does not meet the specification is a nonconformity, recorded in a nonconformity report (NCR). The buyer can reject it, ask for repair, or accept it as it is, often called a concession.
A deviation the buyer accepted during the bid evaluation still has to appear in the contract or purchase order. If it does not, the original specification may prevail.
In quality management and pharmaceutical manufacturing, "deviation" usually means a departure from an approved procedure or specification during production. In bids and tenders, it means the declared departures in the offer.
Example: a technical deviation on a valve body material
A datasheet for a 2-inch gate valve asks for a cast body in ASTM A352 LCC, for a minimum design temperature of −46 °C. In this size, the manufacturer's standard is a forged body to API 602, in ASTM A350 LF2 Class 1. Both materials are impact tested at −46 °C, but LF2 is not the material the datasheet names.
The supplier can source a cast LCC body, or offer forged LF2 and declare it. Declared, the line in the technical deviation list reads:
| Reference | Requirement | Offered | Status | Reason and impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Datasheet, p. 4, item 3 | Cast body ASTM A352 LCC, −46 °C | Forged body ASTM A350 LF2 Class 1, impact tested at −46 °C | Deviation, alternative offered | Manufacturer's standard construction in this size. Same minimum design temperature. Subject to buyer approval |
Calling the alternative equivalent does not make it compliant. Under World Bank rules, standards and materials named in the specification are descriptive, and a bidder may offer others if it demonstrates substantial equivalence (World Bank, ITB 16.5). The supplier still has to declare the substitution and prove it, for example with the material data and impact test requirements of both grades.
Undeclared, the buyer reads the offer as LCC. The forged body surfaces at inspection, against the material certificates, after the price is fixed.
Deviation and related terms
| Term | What it is | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Technical deviation | The offer departs from a stated technical requirement, with the reason and what is offered instead | Forged LF2 body instead of cast LCC |
| Commercial deviation | The offer departs from the commercial or contractual terms | Payment 30 days from delivery instead of 60 days from acceptance |
| Exception | Often a synonym for deviation. Where tenders distinguish the two, more often used for commercial terms | Exception to the delivery penalty clause |
| Clarification | A question to the buyer, or the buyer's question to the supplier, that settles what a requirement means | Datasheet says 316L, general specification says duplex: which applies? |
| Exclusion | Part of the scope the offer does not supply. Excluding scope the tender asks for is itself a departure from the tender | Installation and site testing not included |
| Assumption | A condition the offer relies on where the package is silent | Lifting equipment at site provided by the buyer |
| Reservation | A condition that limits acceptance of the requirements, often commercial or contractual | Liability capped at the contract value |
| Qualification | A condition attached to the offer as a whole. A bid carrying many conditions is called a qualified bid. Not to be confused with bidder qualification, the check of experience and capacity | Offer valid only if the buyer accepts the supplier's general terms |
| Alternative bid | A complete second solution offered next to the compliant one. Many tenders do not consider alternatives unless they invite them (World Bank, ITB 13) | A second offer with a different valve type |
| Nonconformity | After the order: a product or document that does not meet the agreed requirement. A deviation is declared before; a nonconformity is found after | Certificate 3.1 delivered where 3.2 was ordered |
Minor and material deviations
Not every deviation weighs the same. Under World Bank rules, a deviation is material when, if accepted, it would substantially affect the scope, quality or performance of the goods, or substantially limit the buyer's rights or the supplier's obligations under the contract. It is also material when correcting it would unfairly affect the other bidders (World Bank, ITB 29).
A bid with a material deviation is rejected as non-responsive, and it cannot be made responsive afterwards by correcting the deviation. A deviation that is not material does not make the bid non-responsive. The buyer may waive it or, where it can be quantified, adjust the bid price for comparison (World Bank, ITB 30). Private buyers set their own rules, and some RFQs accept no deviations at all. The question behind most technical bid evaluations is the same: does this change what we are buying?
Take the valve in the example. If the supplier offered a body in ASTM A216 WCB for the same −46 °C service, the deviation would be material. WCB is a carbon steel casting supplied without impact testing, normally used down to −29 °C. Below that temperature, codes and project specifications call for impact-tested material, such as A352 LCB or LCC. The change affects safe operation, not only the paperwork, and buyers usually reject it.
How suppliers record technical deviations
Many buyers ask for a technical deviation list, also called a deviation schedule or a statement of deviations and exceptions (World Bank, ITB 16.3). When the tender includes a form for it, use that form. A deviation written only in a cover letter or a datasheet may be overlooked or disregarded.
Each line carries:
- the source: document, page and clause;
- the requirement as written;
- what is offered instead;
- the reason;
- the impact on performance, price or delivery, where it matters.
A compliance matrix goes one step further: every requirement gets a status, compliant or not, so the buyer can check nothing was skipped. The two documents must agree line by line. Commercial deviations usually go in a separate list, against the buyer's terms and conditions.
How Loonar helps
Deviation Analysis matches each requirement in the package to the document that proves you meet it. It classifies each one as fully compliant, partial deviation, full deviation or missing info, with the citation behind every call. Loonar drafts the technical deviation list; your engineers review every line before it goes in the offer. For commercial deviations, T&C Analysis checks the buyer's terms clause by clause against your approved positions.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a technical and a commercial deviation?
A technical deviation concerns the product or service: materials, ratings, tests, documents. A commercial deviation concerns the terms: payment, liability, warranty, delivery penalties. Many tenders ask for them in separate lists, often called deviations and exceptions.
What is the difference between a deviation and an exception?
Often none: many tenders use the two words together, as in a "list of deviations and exceptions". Where they are distinguished, "exception" is more often used for the commercial terms and "deviation" for the technical specification. Follow the wording of the tender.
Is it better to declare a deviation or to comply?
Comply when the cost and lead time allow it. When they do not, declare the deviation with the reason and the alternative. Many tenders state that any requirement not listed as a deviation is deemed accepted, so an undeclared departure becomes a commitment the supplier has not priced.
Can a technical deviation get a bid rejected?
Yes, when it is material. Under World Bank rules, a deviation is material when it substantially affects the scope, quality or performance of the goods, limits the buyer's rights or the supplier's obligations, or would be unfair to other bidders if corrected. A bid with a material deviation is rejected as non-responsive.
Who decides on technical deviations?
The buyer accepts or rejects them, usually through the engineer who owns the specification during the technical bid evaluation. On the supplier side, engineering decides what can be offered, and the bid or sales lead checks the effect on price and delivery before the list goes out.