Glossary
Bid / no-bid decision
Loonar · Updated 12 November 2026
A bid / no-bid decision is a supplier's recorded choice on whether to answer an RFQ or tender. It weighs technical fit, commercial terms, capacity, the chance of winning and the cost of preparing the offer. It is usually taken in stages, from the first read of the package or earlier, and reviewed when deviations or terms turn out worse.
Also called: go / no-go decision, bid decision, bid qualification.
When the decision is taken
The decision is usually taken in stages. It may start when an opportunity is identified, before any RFQ exists, and is reviewed as the package, the technical requirements and the commercial risks become clearer. Once the RFQ arrives, three gates are common:
- After the first read. The scope, the main requirements, the contract terms and the deadline. Bid, no-bid, or bid subject to checks.
- Before pricing. The requirement list, the compliance matrix and the first deviations are known. The decision is confirmed or reversed before the estimating hours are spent.
- Before submission. The final offer, price, deviations and residual risks are reviewed. Management gives final bid approval, or decides to withdraw the offer. Many companies call this gate bid approval or tender approval rather than a new bid / no-bid decision.
The first gate is the hardest, because it comes when the team knows least. That is why it should be reviewed, not treated as final.
The criteria
| Criterion | Question | Where the answer is |
|---|---|---|
| Technical fit | Which requirements can we not meet, and are any of them critical? | Specification, datasheets, requirement list |
| Rules on deviations | Does the tender accept declared deviations? | Instructions to bidders |
| Commercial terms | Are liability, liquidated damages, payment and warranty acceptable? | Commercial conditions, contract draft |
| Schedule and capacity | Can we deliver on time with our current workshop loading? | Delivery requirement, production plan |
| Evaluation basis | Is the award on lowest price, or on published quality criteria? | Evaluation criteria |
| Eligibility and position with the buyer | Are we eligible to take part, and how competitive is our position? An approved vendor list can be a condition of entry; an incumbent affects the chance of winning | Prequalification requirements, approved vendor list, account history |
| Cost of bidding | How many engineering hours, type tests or samples does the offer need? | Requirement list, bid schedule |
Under World Bank rules, for example, the award goes to the "Most Advantageous Bid", determined only with the criteria and method stated in the bidding document. In the one-envelope bidding document for goods, it is the bid that meets the qualification criteria, is substantially responsive and has the lowest evaluated cost (World Bank, ITB 34). Procedures that use rated criteria can instead award on the highest combined technical and financial score. Read the evaluation method before you score your chances. Private buyers often do not publish their criteria, which makes the position with the buyer harder to judge.
Scoring, and its limit
Many teams score each criterion in a bid / no-bid matrix. Some criteria carry more weight than others, and minimum thresholds can be set for critical areas. A score keeps decisions consistent across bids and makes the reasons visible. Its limit, and the reason knock-out criteria are assessed separately from the total: a single knock-out criterion outweighs any total. Uncapped liability your company will not accept, or a type test that cannot be completed before the delivery date, ends the discussion whatever the other scores say.
Example: a valve package
An RFQ for 2-inch gate valves for −46 °C service asks for a cast ASTM A352 LCC body, a fugitive-emissions type test of the valve to ISO 15848-1, tightness class BH at −46 °C, and delivery in 16 weeks ex works.
-
Material. The supplier's standard design uses a forged ASTM A350 LF2 body, not the specified cast LCC body.
-
Qualification. Its valve has an API 624 fugitive-emissions type test. API 624 covers rising-stem valves with graphite packing and does not test at −46 °C, so it does not demonstrate the specified ISO 15848-1 performance.
-
Delivery. Its current lead time is 22 weeks.
-
If the instructions to bidders allow declared deviations, the team may bid, with two technical deviations and the ISO type test quoted as an option. The delivery deviation is declared too. A declared deviation is a proposal: the bid holds only if the buyer accepts the material substitution and the alternative qualification.
-
If the RFQ accepts no deviations, the same facts point to no-bid, unless the cast body, the type test and the delivery can all be met at a price and lead time the team accepts.
The facts are the same. The rules of the tender change the decision.
How to decline
A no-bid is part of the relationship with the buyer. Send it in writing, before the deadline, with a short reason where you can give one: "We are unable to meet the requested delivery of 16 weeks" helps the buyer more than silence. Return or destroy the documents if a confidentiality agreement requires it.
Objections, and what holds up
"You cannot win what you do not bid." True, and every bid costs engineering hours that other offers do not get. A team that bids on everything spreads the same hours over more offers, and the strongest opportunities get less attention.
"Declining damages the relationship." Silence does more damage. A reasoned decline, sent on time, tells the buyer what to change next time and keeps you on the list.
"We cannot judge on day one." That is why the decision has gates. The first one only needs the knock-out criteria; the next ones use the requirement list and the deviations.
"It is a gut decision anyway." Experience matters, but write the reasons down. Comparing past bid decisions with the outcomes shows which criteria predicted a win.
How Loonar helps
The decision stays with your team. Loonar shortens the time to the facts behind it. RFQ Analysis extracts the requirements from the package, each traced to its source page. Deviation Analysis classifies each requirement as fully compliant, partial deviation, full deviation or missing info. T&C Analysis checks the buyer's terms clause by clause against your approved positions. Together, they give your bid team the facts for each gate, from the first read to final approval.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between bid / no-bid and go / no-go?
Often none. Where teams distinguish them, go / no-go decides whether to pursue an opportunity before an RFQ exists, and bid / no-bid decides whether to answer a specific RFQ. Some teams run a final go / no-go on the finished offer before submission.
Who makes the bid / no-bid decision?
Usually the sales lead or bid manager proposes it, with input from engineering, operations and finance. Above a value or risk threshold set by the company, management approves it. What matters is that the reasons are written down.
Which criteria matter most?
The knock-out criteria come first: a requirement you cannot meet in a tender that accepts no deviations, contract terms your company does not accept, a delivery date you cannot reach. If none applies, weigh technical fit, commercial terms, the chance of winning and the cost of bidding.
Should you tell the buyer you are not bidding?
Yes, in writing and before the deadline, usually with a short reason. Buyers plan around the number of offers they expect, and a reasoned decline keeps you on the bidder list. Return or destroy the tender documents if a confidentiality agreement requires it.
Can a bid decision change after it is taken?
Yes. A decision to bid can be reversed at the next gate, for example when the requirement list shows critical deviations or the contract terms come back worse after clarification. Withdrawing early costs less than an offer that cannot be honoured.